Five flats in Iqbal's completed Thane tower are still unsold, and none of them costs the firm any tax on notional rent yet. That changes on a date the law fixes rather than the market. The tax on unsold inventory begins when a builder's unlet stock loses its nil annual value, two years after the end of the financial year in which the completion certificate was obtained, and from then each empty flat is taxed on rent nobody pays. What was section 23(5) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is section 21(5) of the Income-tax Act, 2025. Here is how its clock runs, what the register shows about completed stock, and where developers misread the date.
Key takeaways
- A building held as stock-in-trade and not let has a nil annual value for the period up to two years from the end of the financial year in which its completion certificate is obtained, under section 21(5) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, formerly section 23(5) of the 1961 Act.
- The window was one year when the Finance Act, 2017 introduced it and became two years with the Finance Act, 2019; before it existed, courts had in some cases held unsold flats held as stock taxable as house property.
- After the window, each unsold, unlet flat is taxed on the rent it could reasonably fetch, less municipal taxes paid and the 30 percent standard deduction, although the builder receives nothing.
- The clock runs from the competent authority's certificate, not from the register's Completed status or the completion date a MahaRERA registration files.
- As updated on 11 October 2026, 1,317 of the 1,510 Completed MahaRERA registrations that file the building table with unsold units still file at least one unsold unit, 26,246 of 126,626 units: the promoters' last filed word, not a count of unsold flats today.
Iqbal's five flats and a date in August 2025
Iqbal (our illustrative Thane builder) runs three active projects; this is another of his projects, a finished one. It is the 48-flat tower from our section 43CA story, where he sold one of six remaining flats inside the 110 percent band and held the rest at list price rather than discount past it. Five flats are still unsold. The tower's occupancy certificate is dated August 2025, which falls in the financial year ending 31 March 2026, so the five flats have a nil annual value until 31 March 2028. From tax year 2028-29, any of them still unsold and unlet is taxed on notional rent.
His chartered accountant put a number on it. If each flat could let for about Rs 25,000 a month, its annual value is Rs 3 lakh; less Rs 20,000 of municipal tax the firm pays, Rs 2.8 lakh; less the 30 percent standard deduction, Rs 1.96 lakh of income per flat per year. Five flats make Rs 9.8 lakh a year of taxable income from flats that earn nothing. Iqbal added 31 March 2028 to the dashboard where he keeps his QPR deadlines. Names and numbers in this story are illustrative.
What the rule says, in plain terms
House property is taxed on its annual value: broadly, the rent a property might reasonably be expected to fetch in a year, or the rent it actually earns if that is higher, less the municipal taxes the owner paid. Section 21 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 sets this out, and section 22 then allows a standard deduction of 30 percent. A developer's unsold flats are buildings it owns, so on that logic they carry an annual value even though they are stock. The owner's side of the same rules, for a flat kept empty, is in tax on a second house property.
Section 21(5) is the relief. Where a building held as stock-in-trade is not let, its annual value is nil for the period up to two years from the end of the financial year in which the certificate of completion of construction is obtained from the competent authority. The 1961 Act's section 23(5) said the same: the Finance Act, 2017 inserted it with a one-year window, and the Finance Act, 2019 extended it to two. Before 2017, courts had held in some cases that unsold flats held as stock were taxable as house property, and the window was written as relief from that.
An analogy: free days at a container yard. A port gives an importer a set number of free days after a container lands. After that, demurrage runs every day the box sits there, whether or not anyone wants what is inside. Section 21(5) gives a completed tower's unsold flats their free days, counted to a 31 March rather than from the day the certificate arrives, and after that the meter runs on every flat still standing empty.
Three conditions, all needed. The flat must be stock-in-trade, not a flat the firm holds as an investment or uses itself. It must stand unlet; a flat the firm lets is taxed on its rent like any let house. And the window is measured from the certificate of completion, which in Maharashtra is the planning authority's certificate at the end of construction, filed on MahaRERA under the title "Occupancy Certificate" or "Completion Certificate". Where a building receives part occupancy certificates, which certificate starts the clock for which flats is a point to settle with your CA. The application and the part OC route are in getting the occupancy certificate.
Which date counts. The register's Completed status and the completion date a registration files are the promoter's filings, not the certificate. The register records when a certificate was uploaded, never when the authority issued it, so the date for the tax file is the one printed on the certificate itself.
How much completed stock the register shows
The register cannot say how many unsold flats exist today, but it shows what promoters last filed. As updated on 11 October 2026, only 1,510 of the 21,686 Completed MahaRERA registrations file the building table that carries unsold units and are not plotted layouts. Of those, 1,317 file at least one unsold unit: 26,246 unsold units of 126,626 units in all, 20.7 percent. Two cautions travel with these figures. The building table is a recent filing, filed mostly by recently completed projects, which is why the older groups below are small. And a completed registration's sales figure is the promoter's last filed word and may not be refreshed after completion, so this is what the filings last said, not a measured stock of unsold flats today, and never a market's unsold inventory.
Source: ReraGenie analysis of the 1,510 Completed MahaRERA registrations that file the building table with unsold units, plotted layouts excluded, as updated on 11 October 2026. Unsold units: 24,558 of 116,245; 1,448 of 8,172; 213 of 1,891; 27 of 318. The table is a recent filing, so the older groups are small, and a completed registration's sales figure is the promoter's last filed word, not a count of unsold flats today.
Read the chart with the window in mind. Unsold flats in a project whose certificate came in 2025-26 have a nil annual value to 31 March 2028. For the 94 registrations that file completion in 2023 or 2024 and still file unsold units, a certificate issued in those years puts the end of the window between 31 March 2025 and 31 March 2027, so any flat there still unsold and unlet may already be carrying notional rent.
The market explains why the question is live. ANAROCK's figures for the quarter to September 2026, reported by Business Today on 29 September 2026, put unsold housing stock across its top seven cities at about 6,30,590 units, up 12 percent on a year earlier, with about 37,500 units launched in MMR in the quarter against about 31,750 sold. Ready stock has been a small slice of such totals: in March 2020 ANAROCK counted about 78,000 ready-to-move unsold homes across the same cities, around 12 percent of unsold stock at the time, and put 45 percent of them in MMR and Pune.
Where developers get it wrong
- Dating the clock from the wrong event. Not the register's Completed status, not possession, not the last sale and not the certificate's anniversary: the end of the financial year in which the certificate was obtained, then two years. A certificate dated in April buys almost a year more than one dated the previous March.
- Taking the upload date for the issue date. The register records when a certificate was uploaded, not when it was issued. Put the date printed on the certificate in the tax file.
- Assuming a let flat keeps the relief. The nil value is written for stock that stands unlet. A flat the firm lets to cover costs is taxed on its rent like any let house.
- Discounting past the band to beat the clock. On Iqbal's numbers one unsold flat carries about Rs 1.96 lakh of notional income a year once the window closes, while selling a Rs 1 crore flat at Rs 90 lakh adds Rs 10 lakh of deemed income at once under section 53. Run both before choosing; section 43CA, now section 53 has the arithmetic.
- Forgetting what arrives at completion. GST on the development rights attributable to flats still unbooked at completion falls due through reverse charge, as GST for real estate developers sets out. The income tax window starts later and closes on its own date.
Put three dates in the tax file for every completed project: the date printed on the completion or occupancy certificate, the 31 March that ends its financial year, and the 31 March two years later. The last one is the day each unsold, unlet flat starts carrying notional rent.
Your own project's free page on reragenie.com shows the units booked as you last filed them and whether the occupancy certificate slot holds a document, with its upload date: the two facts a lender or a buyer reads before asking about your unsold flats.
What the project analysis shows for unsold stock
Holding or discounting is a judgement about how fast the remaining flats will move, and the filings carry no prices or rents, so no report can tell you a flat's notional rent. ReraGenie's Rs 2,999 project analysis, built from the filings and selected filed documents, gives the evidence on pace instead. Its absorption cross-section sets sold share against project age, many projects photographed on one day and never a sales history, so you can see whether five unsold flats is ordinary for a tower of that age nearby. Its record of completed projects' cycle time and the share with an occupancy certificate uploaded shows how completions run around you. And its possession landing schedule, with an overdue bucket, shows how much new stock is due to land beside yours inside your window. How to read the same filings yourself is in reading a micro-market from filings; the project analysis assembles them for one location.
The one-line summary
A builder's unsold, unlet flats are free of notional rent until two years after the end of the financial year in which the completion certificate came; date that clock from the certificate, not the register, and weigh the rent it starts against the discount that would clear the flats.
Methodology and sources
- Income-tax Act, 2025, sections 21(5), 21 and 22, formerly sections 23(5), 23 and 24 of the Income-tax Act, 1961; the window inserted by the Finance Act, 2017 with one year and extended to two by the Finance Act, 2019.
- ANAROCK, quarter to September 2026, as reported by Business Today on 29 September 2026; ANAROCK, ready-to-move unsold stock at March 2020.
- ReraGenie analysis of 56,194 published MahaRERA projects, as updated on 11 October 2026. Rents, taxes and flat counts in the story are illustrative.
This article is educational and not tax advice. Confirm the figures for your own case with a chartered accountant.
Evaluating a micro-market or a land parcel?
The ReraGenie project analysis reads the filings around your parcel: supply, absorption and promoter records. Rs 2,999 per project; the area market report is a flat Rs 2,999 per pincode.
See the project analysis