The last flats in a finished tower are the hardest to sell, and the buyer who finally turns up usually wants a discount. For a Maharashtra developer the question is not only how low to go but how low the tax law lets the price stand. Section 43CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961, now section 53 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, answers it: when a builder sells land or a building it holds as stock-in-trade for less than the stamp duty value, and that value is more than 110 percent of the price, the stamp duty value is treated as the sale price. The buyer and an individual seller face mirror rules on the same valuation. Here is how the band works, why it behaves as a cliff, and where the ready reckoner sits in 2026.

Key takeaways

  • What was section 43CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is section 53 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 from 1 April 2026: on a sale of land or a building held as stock-in-trade, a stamp duty value above 110 percent of the price replaces the price in computing business income.
  • The band is measured on the price, so the deepest discount it protects is about 9.09 percent below the stamp duty value; at 10 percent below, the valuation is 111.1 percent of the price and the band is crossed.
  • Once the band is crossed the whole gap is taxed, not just the part beyond it: on a flat valued at Rs 1 crore and sold for Rs 90 lakh, the extra income is Rs 10 lakh.
  • An individual selling a flat held as an investment (section 78, formerly 50C) and the buyer (section 92(2)(m), formerly 56(2)(x)) face mirror rules on the same valuation.
  • Maharashtra raised ready reckoner rates from 1 April 2025, by 7.72 percent in Thane city, and reports on 1 April 2026 said the state kept them unchanged for 2026-27.

Iqbal's last six flats

Iqbal (our illustrative Thane builder) runs three active projects, but the flats on his desk this month sit in a fourth, finished one: a 48-flat tower the firm completed with its occupancy certificate in August 2025. Six flats were still unsold in mid-2026. A buyer offered Rs 88 lakh for one whose stamp duty value, worked out from the ready reckoner, came to Rs 1 crore.

His chartered accountant did the arithmetic in two lines. At Rs 88 lakh the valuation is 113.6 percent of the price, past the 110 percent band, so the firm would be taxed as if it had sold for Rs 1 crore: Rs 12 lakh of income it never received. The lowest price the band protects is Rs 90.91 lakh. Iqbal countered at Rs 92 lakh, the buyer accepted once the buyer's own adviser had checked that side of the deal, and the firm held the other five flats at their list price rather than repeat the exercise. Names and numbers in this story are illustrative.

What the rule says, in plain terms

Section 53 applies to the transfer of land or a building, or both, that is not a capital asset in the seller's hands. For a developer that is its stock-in-trade: every unsold flat, whether the tower is under construction or finished. Where the price received or accruing is less than the stamp duty value, meaning the value a state authority adopts or assesses for stamp duty, the stamp duty value is deemed to be the full value of the consideration in computing business income. The exception is the band: if the stamp duty value does not exceed 110 percent of the price, the price stands.

The band has widened over time. A 5 percent tolerance was added in 2018, and the Finance Act, 2020 widened it to 10 percent, the 110 percent the 2025 Act keeps.

The date that fixes the value. The valuation is normally read on the date the transfer is registered. Where the agreement fixing the price was made earlier, the value on the agreement date may be used instead, but only if some of the price was received through a specified banking or electronic mode on or before that date. A booking paid in cash does not qualify. Whether a particular booking form or allotment letter is the agreement fixing the price is a question your CA will want to see the paper for.

An analogy: the weighbridge tolerance. A truck that crosses a weighbridge within the tolerance pays on the weight its papers declare. Over the tolerance, the bridge's reading replaces the papers, all of it, not just the excess. Section 53 treats your agreement value the same way: inside 110 percent your price is the price; outside it the government's valuation replaces your price entirely.

The mirror rules: one valuation, three taxpayers

The same valuation feeds three rules, one for each person at the table.

WhoIncome-tax Act, 1961Income-tax Act, 2025When the valuation is too far above the price
A developer selling land or flats held as stockSection 43CASection 53A stamp duty value above 110 percent of the price becomes the sale price in business income
An individual selling a flat held as an investmentSection 50CSection 78A stamp duty value above 110 percent of the price becomes the sale price in capital gains
The buyer of the flatSection 56(2)(x)Section 92(2)(m)The gap can be taxed as the buyer's income; under the 1961 Act's version, only where it exceeded the higher of Rs 50,000 and 10 percent of the price

The buyer's rule can decide whether a discount survives the negotiation. The buyer pays stamp duty on the valuation whatever the price, and a discount wide enough to be taxed as the buyer's income is one the buyer's own adviser will raise. The buyer's rule carries the same agreement-date proviso as the developer's. The buyer's half of the same table is in ready reckoner rates.

The ready reckoner in 2026, and the market behind the discount

The valuation all three rules read is Maharashtra's Annual Statement of Rates. The last revision took effect on 1 April 2025, and Housing.com's summary of it put the average increase at 3.89 percent across the state, 3.39 percent in Mumbai and 7.72 percent in Thane city. Reports on 1 April 2026 said the state had kept the rates unchanged for 2026-27, so a valuation worked out this year holds until the next notification. What a revision does to a developer's premiums and other cost lines is in ready reckoner rates as a cost driver.

The pressure to discount comes from the market. ANAROCK's figures for the quarter to September 2026, reported by Business Today on 29 September 2026, put unsold housing stock across its top seven cities at about 6,30,590 units, 12 percent more than a year earlier, and counted about 37,500 units launched in MMR in the quarter against about 31,750 sold. On the register, 21,686 of the 56,194 published MahaRERA projects show Completed, as updated on 11 October 2026, and every one with a flat still unsold is a place this rule can bite.

Here is the cliff on one flat.

Extra income deemed on one flat, by how far the price sits below a Rs 1 crore stamp duty value(Rs lakh added to business income, illustrative)
5% below: price Rs 95 lakhRs 0 (inside the band)
9% below: price Rs 91 lakhRs 0 (inside the band)
10% below: price Rs 90 lakhRs 10 lakh
15% below: price Rs 85 lakhRs 15 lakh

Source: Illustrative arithmetic under section 53 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (formerly section 43CA of the 1961 Act): a Rs 1 crore stamp duty value is 105.3, 109.9, 111.1 and 117.6 percent of prices of Rs 95, 91, 90 and 85 lakh; above 110 percent the whole gap is added. Not a tax computation; the extra income is taxed at the seller's own rate.

Between 9 and 10 percent below the valuation the result jumps from nothing to the whole gap. At every discount past that edge the firm is taxed on money it never received, in the year of the sale.

Warning

The band is a cliff, not a deductible. A sale 10 percent below the stamp duty value is not taxed on the sliver beyond the band; it is taxed on the whole Rs 10 lakh. If a deal needs a discount past about 9 percent, price the tax on the entire gap into the decision before you sign, and record why the flat is worth less than its valuation in case you need to dispute the valuation itself.

Where developers get it wrong

  1. Reading the band as 10 percent off the valuation. It is 110 percent of the price. The deepest discount inside it is 1 minus 1/1.1 of the valuation, about 9.09 percent, which on a Rs 1 crore flat is a price of Rs 90.91 lakh, not Rs 90 lakh.
  2. Pricing the flat without pricing the buyer. The buyer pays stamp duty on the valuation whatever the agreed price, and a wide enough gap can be taxed as the buyer's income under section 92(2)(m). A discount that only works for one side of the table rarely closes.
  3. Ignoring the date. The valuation is read on registration unless the agreement-date proviso applies, and it applies only where part of the price came through a banking or electronic channel by the agreement date. With 2026-27 rates unchanged the date costs nothing this year; across a 1 April revision it can move the valuation of a flat agreed in March.
  4. Assuming finished stock is outside the rule. A flat in a completed tower is still stock-in-trade. GST stops at the completion certificate, as GST for real estate developers sets out, but section 53 does not.
  5. Forgetting it covers land. A developer selling land held as stock, rather than flats, meets the same rule. Land moved through a joint development raises its own stamp and tax questions, set out in JDA tax and stamp duty.

Before deciding how deep the last flats need to go, look at what is competing for the same buyers. Every registered project around yours has a free page on reragenie.com with its possession timeline and, where filed, its units booked, and the district pages show the district's registrations by status.

What the project analysis shows when you price the last flats

The filings carry no flat prices or rates, so no report can tell you a flat's valuation or what a neighbour accepted. What ReraGenie's Rs 2,999 project analysis gives you is the demand side of the decision, built from the filings and selected filed documents. It sets out the registered projects within 2 km and 5 km of your filed location with their supply, so you know how many other flats your buyer is choosing between. It draws an absorption cross-section of sold share against project age, many projects photographed on one day and never a sales history, which shows whether your tower's pace is unusual for its age. And its possession landing schedule, with an overdue bucket, shows how much new stock is due to land beside yours. Reading those neighbours one filing at a time is covered in your competitor's QPRs; for one pincode with at least 20 registrations, the area report tables the active registrations with their bookings per month where both inputs are filed.

The one-line summary

Section 53, the old section 43CA, lets a developer's price stand only while the stamp duty value is within 110 percent of it; past that line the whole gap is taxed, and the buyer and individual sellers meet mirror rules on the same valuation.

Methodology and sources

  • Income-tax Act, 2025, sections 53, 78 and 92(2)(m), formerly sections 43CA, 50C and 56(2)(x) of the Income-tax Act, 1961; the tolerance widened from 5 to 10 percent by the Finance Act, 2020; the 120 percent window of 12 November 2020 to 30 June 2021.
  • Ready reckoner revision effective 1 April 2025, as summarised by Housing.com; reports of 1 April 2026 on the 2026-27 rates.
  • ANAROCK, quarter to September 2026, as reported by Business Today on 29 September 2026.
  • ReraGenie analysis of 56,194 published MahaRERA projects, as updated on 11 October 2026. Every sale figure in this article is illustrative.

This article is educational and not tax advice. Confirm the figures for your own case with a chartered accountant.

Evaluating a micro-market or a land parcel?

The ReraGenie project analysis reads the filings around your parcel: supply, absorption and promoter records. Rs 2,999 per project; the area market report is a flat Rs 2,999 per pincode.

See the project analysis