The seal looks official, and that is the trouble. A notarised agreement for flat sales comes on stamp paper, with a notary's round seal and register number on the last page, and to most buyers it reads as a finished deal. It is not one. In Maharashtra a notary confirms who signed a document and when; ownership of a flat moves only through a document registered with the sub-registrar. The space between those two acts is where resale buyers lose money, where some new-flat buyers are asked to pay too early, and where a flat can be sold twice. Here is what each document does, what the law says, and what to do if a notarised agreement is all you hold.
Key takeaways
- A notary attests that a document was signed by the people named in it; notarisation registers nothing and transfers no ownership of a flat.
- Under section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, a sale of immovable property worth Rs 100 or more can be made only by a registered instrument, and a contract for sale does not of itself create any interest in the property.
- Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908 denies an unregistered document that needed registration any effect on the property; it may still be evidence of the contract in a suit for specific performance.
- The Supreme Court held in Suraj Lamp and Industries v State of Haryana (11 October 2011) that an agreement to sell, a power of attorney and a will do not convey title; only a registered deed of conveyance does.
- Under the Maharashtra Stamp Act, an agreement for sale that hands over possession is charged duty as a conveyance, so one notarised on a nominal stamp paper carries unpaid duty with it.
Neha's file with a seal on every page
Neha (illustrative, as our stories always are), 34, a marketing manager, is weeks from the keys to her 2BHK in a Mulund society redevelopment, bought with a Rs 60 lakh bank loan on an agreement registered at the sub-registrar. Before Mulund she turned down a one-bedroom MHADA flat on resale in an older lottery building in the eastern suburbs, and the reason was a document that looked more finished than it was. Names and numbers in this story are illustrative.
The seller had bought from the original allottee in the third year after allotment. His proof was a notarised agreement typed on a Rs 500 stamp paper, recording that the allottee had handed over possession on signing, and a power of attorney signed the same day that called itself irrevocable: notarised, and never registered, although in Maharashtra an irrevocable one signed after March 2013 must be. Neha ran three checks before paying anything. IGR Maharashtra's free e-search on the building's survey number showed no registered document naming the seller. The notary's entry, when she asked for it, confirmed one thing only: two men had signed before that notary on that date. And the agreement's own words, possession on signing, made it the kind of paper the Stamp Act charges as a sale, on which nobody had paid a sale's duty.
So the seller held a contract, a signed authority and a set of keys, and no title. The only person who could sign a deed that would give her one was the allottee, and nobody knew where he lived; the MHADA resale guide tells the board's side of the same file. She asked for the allottee's signature on a registered deed before any token. The seller offered a lower price instead, and she walked away.
What the law actually says
Notarisation. Section 8 of the Notaries Act, 1952 lets a notary verify, authenticate, certify or attest the execution of an instrument. In court a notarised document carries, at most, a limited presumption about its execution and signatures; it proves nothing about whether its contents are true or whether the seller owned the flat the document deals with. A notary is not a registering officer, and nothing a notary attests appears in IGR's index.
Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. A sale of tangible immovable property worth Rs 100 or more can be made only by a registered instrument. The same section says a contract for sale, a promise that a sale will take place on settled terms, does not of itself create any interest in or charge on the property.
Sections 17 and 49 of the Registration Act, 1908. Section 17 makes registration compulsory for documents that create or transfer rights in immovable property worth Rs 100 or more. Since a 2001 amendment, section 17(1A) adds one more: an agreement to transfer immovable property for consideration, if the buyer wants to rely on it to protect possession under section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, must be registered, or it has no effect for that purpose. Section 49 then says what non-registration costs: a document that needed registration does not affect the property and cannot be received as evidence of a transaction affecting it. Its proviso keeps one door open. The unregistered agreement may be received as evidence of the contract in a suit for specific performance, or of a collateral transaction, and the Supreme Court confirmed in 2023 that an unregistered agreement to sell is admissible for that purpose.
Suraj Lamp and Industries v State of Haryana (2011). A bench of three judges, in a judgment written by Justice R.V. Raveendran, held that a "sale" by an agreement to sell, a general power of attorney and a will is not a transfer at all. Immovable property passes only by a registered deed of conveyance. Such documents can support a suit for specific performance or a part-performance defence where the law allows one, and genuine powers of attorney remain valid for what they are, but they cannot be relied on to claim ownership.
Maharashtra's stamp and registration rules. Four state rules bear on the papers in Neha's file. An irrevocable power of attorney relating to the transfer of immovable property, executed on or after 1 April 2013, must be registered under Maharashtra's amendment to the Registration Act. Explanation I to Article 25 of the Maharashtra Stamp Act treats an agreement to sell under which possession passes, or is agreed to pass, as a conveyance for duty; the Supreme Court applied it in a judgment reported in February 2025 and held that paying duty on a later sale deed does not cure the shortfall on the earlier agreement. And Article 48 charges a power of attorney given for consideration and authorising the attorney to sell immovable property the same duty as a conveyance, on the market value. Under section 34 of the Act, an instrument not duly stamped cannot be used as evidence until the shortfall and a penalty are paid.
New flats: the agreement itself must be registered. Section 13 of the RERA Act, 2016 bars a promoter from taking more than 10 percent of the cost of a flat before a written agreement for sale is executed and registered. For a building outside RERA, section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act sets the same rule at 20 percent of the sale price; since the 2025 amendment that act no longer applies to projects RERA governs, except for a few sections, as MOFA versus RERA explains. A builder who offers a notarised agreement in place of a registered one is offering what both laws rule out, and the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal has ordered a refund with interest where a builder collected money before executing the agreement.
The three documents, compared
| Document | What it transfers | What it proves | The risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notarised agreement for sale | Nothing. It is a promise to sell later and creates no interest in the flat | That the named people signed before a notary on that date | Invisible to an IGR search; if it records possession it owes conveyance duty and cannot be used in evidence until that is paid; the remedy is a suit for specific performance, inside a three-year limit |
| Registered sale deed, or a builder's registered agreement for sale | A sale deed transfers ownership; a registered builder's agreement is the document RERA or MOFA requires before more than 10 or 20 percent is paid | The transaction, its date and the duty paid, on the public index, with an Index II to show for it | It passes only what the seller had: a registered deed from someone without title transfers no more than that person held |
| Power-of-attorney sale: an agreement, a general power of attorney, sometimes a will | Nothing, under Suraj Lamp (2011) | That the owner authorised the attorney to act for the owner, and nothing about the buyer | Title stays with the owner, or the owner's heirs, whose signature is still needed; given for consideration it owes conveyance duty, and an irrevocable one must be registered |
The middle row is the only one that ends in your name on the public record. How that index works, and what its one-page entry shows, is in the Index II guide.
An analogy: the signature check on a cheque
A bank can confirm that the signature on a cheque matches the account holder's. That makes the cheque genuine; it does not put money in your account, and it says nothing about whether the account holds any. Only clearing does that. A notary is the signature check. Registration is the clearing, the moment the transaction enters the record everyone else relies on. A notarised agreement is a cheque the seller has promised to deposit later, and until it clears, the flat stays exactly where it was.
What the numbers say
Registration is the ordinary way a flat changes hands, not an extra formality. In the BMC area alone, 1,50,254 property registrations were recorded in 2025, 6 percent more than in 2024 and the most in 14 years, bringing in Rs 13,487 crore of stamp duty, according to Knight Frank India's year-end figures reported in December 2025.
Source: Knight Frank India, year-end figures as reported by IANS, December 2025
Every one of those documents sits in an index the next buyer can search. A notarised agreement sits in a notary's register and the buyer's drawer. No published figure counts how many flats change hands on notarised paper, and that is the point: transactions that skip registration are the ones no index can count, and no later buyer can find.
If you already hold a notarised agreement: the routes
- A registered deed from the title holder. The cleanest repair. The person who still owns the flat, or that person's heirs, signs a sale deed that is stamped and registered in your name. Everything else is a way of getting there or of getting your money back.
- The stamp duty on the old paper. If your agreement recorded possession, it was chargeable as a conveyance. Paying the shortfall, with the penalty that grows each month, is what makes it usable in evidence at all; take a lawyer's view before you go to the stamp office.
- A suit for specific performance in the civil court, to compel the seller to execute the deed. The unregistered agreement is admissible for this, and the clock is three years, as the questions at the end of this article explain.
- MahaRERA, for a builder flat. A promoter who took more than 10 percent without a registered agreement has breached section 13; a complaint can seek the registered agreement or a refund with interest. How to file a MahaRERA complaint covers the forms.
- The police, where you were cheated. If the same flat was sold to someone else on registered paper, the double sale guide sets out the criminal route alongside the civil ones.
What to do this week
- List every document behind the flat, link by link, and mark which ones were registered. Each registered one has an Index II; each that has none is a gap, however many seals it carries.
- Run IGR's free e-search on the survey or CTS number and the flat number, and save what it shows. A resale chain should run from the builder's agreement to the seller in registered steps, as the chain of title guide shows.
- Read your agreement for the word possession. If it says possession passed or will pass, expect conveyance duty on it.
- Find out who holds title today, and whether that person, or the heirs, can be reached and will sign.
- On a new flat, pay nothing past 10 percent until the agreement is registered, and book the sub-registrar appointment yourself if you must, as registration day describes.
- Put your payments in order: bank transfers, receipts and messages, by date, because a court or MahaRERA will ask for them.
A request to sign on stamp paper before a notary now and register "later" deserves one question: why later? There is rarely a good answer, and the usual one is that something in the chain cannot yet be registered. Until it is, the seller keeps the title and you keep the risk.
If the flat sits in a MahaRERA project, its free ReraGenie page shows the promoter named on the registration, any declared charge with its lender and amount, and the land owners as filed, so you can see who the record says can sell before you sign anything: look the project up.
What registration bought Neha
Neha's Mulund agreement went to the sub-registrar about two weeks after her bank sanctioned the loan, and it is the document her bank lent against. Its entry is in the same index she searched for the MHADA seller and found nothing. When her keys come, nothing about her ownership will depend on a seal, a promise, or a man nobody can find. The habit she kept from the MHADA file is simple: ask which documents were registered before asking about the flat.
What the buyer report adds
For a flat in a covered Maharashtra project, three parts of the Rs 499 ReraGenie buyer report bear on who can actually sell it to you:
- Land and title as five questions: who owns the land as filed, the promoter's right to build and sell, whether the land is mortgaged, what the legal title report concludes and the exceptions it attaches, and any disputes.
- Complaints and cases in plain words, with case numbers, where buyers' disputes with the promoter are recorded.
- What to verify before you book, with each fact carrying its filing date, so the questions you take to the sub-registrar's office are the ones this filing raises.
It includes the project's filed documents as a ZIP and a free 90-day project watch that emails you when the filing changes. A resale in an old building with no MahaRERA registration has no filing to read, and there the chain checks stay yours. See what the buyer report covers.
This article is educational and not legal advice. For a dispute, consult a lawyer who practices before your state's RERA.
Evaluating a project right now?
The ReraGenie buyer report reads every filing for one project and sets out the red flags, the checks that came back clear and what to verify before you book, each fact with its filing date. Rs 499, one time.
See the buyer report