The second buyer usually learns about it last. A registered agreement for the same flat number turns up at the society office, or a bank's legal team finds it, or a stranger arrives with keys. A double sale of flat fraud is old and simple: one flat, two buyers, two sets of paper, and in most versions only one of those sets ever reached a sub-registrar. Which buyer is protected, and what the other can do, turns largely on that one difference. So does the defence, which is a search that costs nothing and a registration you insist on before the money moves.
Key takeaways
- A double sale usually leaves one buyer holding a registered document and the other holding something weaker: an unregistered or notarised agreement, a receipt, or a power of attorney.
- Section 50 of the Registration Act, 1908 gives a duly registered document effect against an unregistered one relating to the same property.
- Section 13 of the RERA Act bars a promoter from taking more than 10 percent of the cost before a written agreement for sale is registered, so a request for more money on unregistered paper is the first warning.
- Cheating that induces delivery of property carries up to seven years and a fine under section 318(4) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita; the police, MahaRERA and a civil court are separate routes.
- NCRB's Crime in India 2023, as reported by PTI, counted 19,803 financial fraud cases in Maharashtra in 2023, up from 15,550 in 2021.
Rohit's agreement, registered from abroad
Rohit (illustrative, as our stories always are), 35, is buying an Rs 86 lakh flat from abroad in a Wakad project whose filing names the Pimpri-Chinchwad Municipal Corporation. He pays through a home loan, possession is still ahead of him, and he paid an Rs 8.6 lakh booking amount against an allotment letter. When the agreement for sale was ready, the sales office suggested he sign it and register it "with the next batch" of buyers in a month or so, and asked for the instalment due on the agreement in the meantime. Names and numbers in this story are illustrative.
He declined, in writing. Nothing beyond the 10 percent he had paid would move until the agreement was registered, which section 13 of the RERA Act requires of the promoter anyway. His brother-in-law in Pune signed and admitted the agreement at the sub-registrar's office under a narrow power of attorney Rohit had sent from abroad, by the route the NRI buyer's playbook sets out. A week later, from his desk overseas, Rohit opened IGR Maharashtra's free e-search, searched the project's survey number for that year, filtered for his flat number, and found one entry: his own agreement, with his name, the flat, the consideration and the stamp duty paid. He saved that Index II page as a PDF, and his lender asked for exactly that page before its first disbursement.
How one flat gets sold twice
In a new project
The commonest version needs no forgery at all. Two people book one flat on forms and receipts, each told it is available, and only one ever reaches a registered agreement. Cash-discounted deals, "pre-launch" bookings and notarised agreements live in the same gap, because a document never registered never appears in the index the next buyer searches.
Two variants come from how projects are put together. In a joint development, some flats belong to the landowner's share, and where the paperwork is loose a flat can be offered by both the landowner and the developer; buying in a joint development project explains how that share is filed. And a flat can be sold and then mortgaged. In a press release of 10 May 2024, the Enforcement Directorate said its money-laundering investigation into a Navi Mumbai developer group had found that the group sold the same flats to several buyers and took loans from an NBFC by mortgaging flats it had already sold, without the buyers' knowledge. The case grew out of Maharashtra Police FIRs for cheating flat buyers; the agency filed its prosecution complaint in August 2021 and provisionally attached properties worth Rs 52.73 crore in May 2024. These are allegations in a case before a special court, not findings.
On resale
On resale, the gap usually sits in the seller's own chain. An owner who once sold on an unregistered agreement or a power of attorney still appears in the registry as the owner, and can sign a registered sale to someone else. Or a holder of a general power of attorney sells while the owner, or the owner's heirs, sell too. The MHADA resale guide walks through the agreement-and-power-of-attorney arrangement that leaves the title where it was.
Every version shares one feature: a gap between paying money and registering a document. Close the gap and most double sales have nowhere to stand.
What the law actually says
Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 makes registration compulsory for a non-testamentary document that creates, assigns or extinguishes any right, title or interest worth Rs 100 or more in immovable property.
Section 50 is the one that decides double sales. A duly registered document of the kinds listed in section 17(1)(a) to (d) takes effect, as regards the property, against every unregistered document relating to the same property and conferring the same rights. Courts have weighed it against other law, including the protection section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act gives a buyer in possession under part performance, so a real dispute turns on its facts. A buyer of an under-construction flat has no possession to point to, which leaves the registered document doing the work.
Section 13(1) of the RERA Act, 2016 bars a promoter from accepting more than 10 percent of the cost as an advance or application fee without first entering into a written agreement for sale and registering it. In a registered project, a request for more money on an unregistered agreement is itself the warning.
Section 318(4) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which replaced section 420 of the Indian Penal Code from 1 July 2024, punishes cheating that dishonestly induces a person to deliver property with up to seven years' imprisonment and a fine.
Section 18(1) of the RERA Act applies when a promoter fails to complete, or is unable to give possession of, a flat in accordance with the agreement for sale: an allottee who withdraws gets back the amount paid, with interest at the prescribed rate, and compensation. A promoter that has sold your flat to someone else is, on its face, unable to give it to you.
One change is pending and is not law. The Department of Land Resources published a draft Registration Bill, 2025 for comment in May 2025 to replace the 1908 Act; among other things, it would make a power of attorney authorising the transfer of immovable property compulsorily registrable. It was still described as a draft in January 2026.
The routes, compared
| Route | Against whom | What it can give you | What it cannot do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Police complaint, under BNS section 318(4) | Whoever cheated: a builder, a seller, an agent | An FIR, an investigation and a prosecution; in large frauds, attachment of the money trail | Return your money by itself, or decide who owns the flat |
| Complaint to MahaRERA | A promoter, for a registered project | A refund with interest and compensation where the promoter cannot give the flat, or directions to the promoter | Reach a resale seller who is not a promoter, or cancel the other buyer's document |
| Civil suit | The seller, and the other buyer | A declaration of your rights, specific performance, cancellation of the later document, or recovery of money | Move quickly: it is usually the slowest of the routes, and carries court fees |
| Written settlement | The promoter or seller | Another flat, or a refund, on agreed terms | Bind anyone who did not sign it; read what it makes you give up first |
The routes are not alternatives: a buyer often uses the police for the fraud and MahaRERA or a civil court for the money or the flat. How to file a MahaRERA complaint covers the forms.
An analogy: the reservation chart
Two passengers board a train holding tickets for the same berth. One booked through the railway, and his name is on the reservation chart pasted on the coach; the other bought a handwritten ticket from a tout. The ticket examiner does not weigh who paid more or who boarded first. He reads the chart.
Registration is the chart for property. A document that never reached the sub-registrar's index is the tout's ticket: perhaps a real promise, but not one the system can see.
What the numbers say
Fraud of every kind has been rising in the state. NCRB's Crime in India 2023, as reported by PTI, counted 19,803 financial fraud cases in Maharashtra in 2023, up from 18,729 in 2022 and 15,550 in 2021. The category is far wider than property, and no published table isolates double sales, so read the direction rather than the total.
Source: NCRB, Crime in India 2023, as reported by PTI
The mortgage half of the pattern can be read in the register. As updated on 7 October 2026, 17,540 published MahaRERA projects answer the question on declared charges, and 2,663 of them, 15.2 percent, declare one: secured lending against the project, with the lender and amount filed. A charge is ordinary construction finance, not a sign of fraud, and an unanswered question does not mean the land is free of one. In a charged project, ask for the lender's no-objection letter naming your flat.
The search before any payment
- 1
1. Read the project's registration
For a new flat: the MahaRERA registration is current, the promoter is the entity named on your receipt, any declared charge is named with its lender, and in a joint development the filed allocation schedule shows whose share the flat is in.
- 2
2. Search the flat on IGR's e-search
Search the survey or CTS number year by year and filter for the flat number. A registered agreement, sale, gift or mortgage of that flat appears; a registered agreement in another name ends the deal.
- 3
3. On resale, trace the chain
Every link back to the builder's first agreement, each buyer becoming the next seller, with no power of attorney standing in for a sale.
- 4
4. Ask in writing
The builder confirms the flat is unsold and names any lender whose release you need; on resale, the society confirms its register of members names the seller.
- 5
5. Register before you pay past 10 percent
Register the agreement within days of signing, find your own Index II entry, and repeat the search once a year.
Source: Registration Act, 1908, sections 17, 23 and 50; RERA Act, 2016, section 13
The method for step 3, link by link, is in the chain of title guide, and the registration day itself is in the registration process guide.
A search shows only what was registered, and that cuts both ways. It will not show an earlier buyer holding a notarised agreement or a power of attorney, which is why steps 3 and 4 exist. And it will not show your own payment until your agreement is registered. If a builder or seller wants money on a document that will never reach the sub-registrar, the document on offer is precisely the one no later buyer's search can find.
Before any of this money moves, ReraGenie's free page for every MahaRERA registration shows whether the registration is current, the declared charges with lender and amount, and complaints against the project with their case numbers: look the project up while the money is still in your account.
If it has already happened: what to do this week
- Get the other document's details. Find the other buyer's Index II on the e-search, with its registration number and date, and apply at the sub-registrar's office for certified copies of both documents.
- Put the money trail in order. Bank transfers, receipts, the allotment letter, emails and messages from the sales office, by date. Cash is the hardest payment to prove.
- Write to the builder or seller. A dated notice stating the facts and asking, within a fixed time, for the flat or the refund.
- Go to the police. A written complaint at the police station with jurisdiction over the property, with copies of the documents, asking for an FIR.
- File at MahaRERA if the project is registered, for a refund with interest under section 18 or for directions to the promoter.
- See a civil lawyer early, about a suit and its time limits.
- Tell your lender if a loan paid any part of it, because its security is the same flat.
What registration bought Rohit
Had Rohit's agreement sat unregistered for the month the sales office suggested, he would have held receipts and a signed paper no index recorded. A registered agreement for the same flat in someone else's name would then have been the document section 50 favours, and his remedies a refund claim and a police complaint rather than his flat. Registered, his agreement is what any later buyer's search finds first. He repeats the search once a year, in five minutes, from abroad.
What the buyer report adds
For a covered Maharashtra project, three parts of the Rs 499 ReraGenie buyer report bear directly on a double-sale risk:
- Land and title as five questions: who owns the land as filed, the promoter's right to build and sell, whether the land is mortgaged, what the legal title report concludes and the exceptions it attaches, and any disputes. Landowners named in the filing, and land under a charge, surface here.
- Complaints and cases in plain words, with case numbers, which is where buyers' complaints against the project are recorded.
- The promoter's other registrations and how they ended, because conduct on earlier projects is part of the same public record.
It includes the project's filed documents as a ZIP and a free 90-day project watch that emails you when the filing changes. See what the buyer report covers.
This article is educational and not legal advice. For a dispute, consult a lawyer who practices before your state's RERA.
Evaluating a project right now?
The ReraGenie buyer report reads every filing for one project and sets out the red flags, the checks that came back clear and what to verify before you book, each fact with its filing date. Rs 499, one time.
See the buyer report