The offer reached Rohit on a Sunday evening through his brother-in-law in Pune: a buyer wanted his flat in a Wakad tower that is still a concrete frame, and would pay Rs 10 lakh over everything Rohit had paid the builder. On an Rs 86 lakh flat, that looks like almost 12 percent in two years. Whether to sell an under-construction flat before possession or hold it is a real fork, and the premium is the least useful number in the offer. What decides it is what the assignment costs, who keeps the stamp duty already paid, and what holding would cost instead.

Key takeaways

  • To sell an under-construction flat before possession, the allottee assigns the registered agreement for sale to a buyer who takes over the remaining instalments, with the builder's consent where the agreement requires it and the lender paid off first.
  • Under Article 5(g-a)(ii) of Schedule I of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, a transfer within three years of the first agreement with the builder gets credit for the duty paid on that agreement, a window in force since 1 May 2022.
  • A booking held more than 24 months from the allotment letter gives a long-term gain taxed at 12.5 percent, and a non-resident seller's buyer deducts tax under section 393(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 from the whole consideration.
  • Measured against everything already paid, including stamp duty, registration and GST the next buyer will not pay again, a premium over the instalments can be close to nothing.

Rohit's offer

Rohit (illustrative, as our stories always are), 35, is buying an Rs 86 lakh flat from abroad in a Wakad project registered in 2024, whose filing names the Pimpri-Chinchwad Municipal Corporation. He paid an Rs 8.6 lakh booking amount, pays the rest through a home loan under a tripartite agreement, and plans to let the flat after possession through his brother-in-law. With his wing past its 12th slab, Rs 51.6 lakh had reached the builder, half his own money and half his bank's. The buyer, found by a Pune broker, offered Rs 61.6 lakh, that sum plus Rs 10 lakh, and would take over the remaining Rs 34.4 lakh of instalments. Names and numbers in this story are illustrative.

The two options, defined honestly

Assigning now transfers your rights under the registered agreement to a buyer who pays you for them and takes over the payments still due. Its strongest case: it ends your exposure to the date, the builder and the market, returns your capital years early and banks any rise in price. Within three years of your agreement, your stamp duty also counts towards your buyer's.

Holding to possession means paying the rest, taking the keys, and letting the flat or living in it. Its strongest case: the stamp duty and GST already paid stay in a flat you keep, there is no transfer fee, and rent starts. Its cost is every risk the assignment would have passed on.

Cancelling, a third exit, ends the booking instead: the builder refunds what it received less the deduction your agreement allows (cancelling under Circular 50/2025), and the stamp duty returns only through a timely refund application.

What an assignment involves in Maharashtra

The builder. If your agreement for sale or allotment letter has a transfer clause, it decides whether the builder must consent, on what conditions and for what fee. Get the consent and fee in writing before agreeing a price, and ask the builder to join the deed of assignment as a confirming party, putting its acknowledgement of the new allottee on record.

The lender. Your tripartite agreement records the bank's interest and binds the builder on a transfer, as the home loan guide explains. So the buyer's money pays off your loan first, your bank releases the original agreement it holds, and the buyer's lender, if any, signs its own tripartite agreement, the order of payments in buying property with existing loan dues.

The stamp duty. The assignment is charged as a conveyance on the flat's market value, at the rate a purchase pays: 7 percent in the Pune area for a male buyer, as the stamp duty guide shows. But under Article 5(g-a)(ii) of Schedule I of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, where a flat bought from the builder is transferred or assigned within three years of the first agreement for sale, the duty paid on that agreement is credited against the duty on the transfer, and the new buyer pays only the difference. The window has been three years since 1 May 2022, and the credit goes to whoever pays the assignment's duty, normally the buyer.

Tip

Write down the date three years from your agreement for sale. Until then, your stamp duty travels with the booking and cuts the next buyer's duty by the same amount, so a fair offer counts it.

The tax. A booking is a capital asset. CBDT counted the holding period of a DDA self-financing flat from the allotment letter (Circular 471, 15 October 1986), and tax tribunals have done the same for builders' allotment letters. Held more than 24 months from that letter, the gain is long-term and taxed at 12.5 percent under section 197 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, formerly section 112, with no indexation option for a non-resident; held 24 months or less, it is taxed at slab rates. How a resident's sale of a finished house is taxed is in capital gains on sale of house.

The deduction, if you live abroad. Your buyer deducts under section 393(2), formerly section 195, from the whole consideration rather than the gain: for a long-term holding, 12.5 percent plus surcharge and 4 percent cess, about 14.3 percent between Rs 50 lakh and Rs 1 crore, as buying from an NRI seller shows. A short deduction is the buyer's liability, so expect the full rate unless you obtain a lower deduction certificate before the sale; otherwise the excess returns only through your Indian return.

The offer, in rupees

What Rohit had put in, all of it:

  • Rs 51.6 lakh of instalments.
  • Rs 6.32 lakh of stamp duty and registration on his agreement: 7 percent of Rs 86 lakh, plus Rs 30,000.
  • Rs 2.58 lakh of GST, 5 percent of the instalments, which an assignment does not return.
  • About Rs 1.5 lakh of pre-EMI interest.

About Rs 62 lakh, against an offer of Rs 61.6 lakh, and the builder quoted a Rs 1 lakh transfer fee the broker expected him to pay: about Rs 1.4 lakh short. The buyer's side explained the premium. New from the builder, whose price for a similar flat had reached Rs 96 lakh, the buyer would pay about Rs 6.72 lakh of duty, 7 percent of Rs 96 lakh, and Rs 4.8 lakh of GST. Taking over Rohit's booking for the same Rs 96 lakh in all, about Rs 70,000 of duty after the Rs 6.02 lakh credit, and Rs 1.72 lakh of GST on the remaining instalments. That Rs 9.1 lakh saving was most of the premium: the buyer would have been paying Rohit back his own taxes.

Then the deduction: about 14.3 percent of Rs 61.6 lakh, roughly Rs 8.8 lakh withheld, while his accountant, counting the duty, registration and GST in the booking's cost, put the gain at about Rs 1.1 lakh before the fee.

Assign now or hold to possession, side by side

Assign nowHold to possession
PriceWhat one buyer pays today: the instalments plus any premiumThe finished flat's value, unknown today
Stamp dutyCharged as a conveyance; within three years, your duty is credited against itAlready paid, part of a flat you keep
Builder's transfer feeWhatever your agreement allows, with consent in writingNone
The lenderYour loan closed first; any lender of the buyer signs a new tripartite agreementDisbursements to possession, then the full EMI
GSTPaid on past instalments, not returned5 percent on each remaining instalment
Income tax12.5 percent if held over 24 months from allotment; slab rates beforeNothing until a sale; rent taxed once let
TDS if you live abroadSection 393(2) on the whole consideration, unless certified lowerYour tenant deducts under section 393(2) from rent
RiskEnds your exposure to the date, the builder and the marketKeeps all three until the keys

How the trade-off is playing out in the market

ANAROCK's figures for July to September 2026 describe the market a booking sells into: in India's top seven cities, developers launched about 1,14,320 homes, 18 percent more than a year earlier, against 1,00,220 sold, 3 percent more, and unsold stock was 12 percent higher than a year before at roughly 6.31 lakh homes. In the same ANAROCK quarter, Pune sold 15,690 homes, 6 percent fewer than a year earlier, and the seven-city average price reached Rs 9,714 per sq ft, up 7 percent on the year but 1 percent on the quarter.

Homes launched and sold in India's top seven cities, July to September 2026(homes)
Launched1,14,320
Sold1,00,220

Source: ANAROCK, July to September 2026, as reported by Business Today on 29 September 2026

For a seller, a buyer of a booking can usually buy a builder's unsold flat instead, so a premium is one buyer's price, not a market price. For a holder, seven-city prices are still rising, slowly, and the bet is on the finished flat and its date. Neither figure picks a path.

An analogy: selling your place in a queue

Selling a booking is selling your place in a long queue, not the thing at its end. The person behind you pays for the time you have already stood there, and pays less when new queues open alongside, which is what 18 percent more launches means. In Maharashtra your place also holds, for three years, the ticket you bought at the start, your stamp duty, so ask to be paid for it.

The framework: six questions that decide it

  1. How long until your agreement's third anniversary? Before it, your stamp duty cuts the next buyer's; after it, the credit is gone.
  2. What have you put in, all of it? Instalments, duty, registration, GST and interest: measure a premium against that total.
  3. Is the gain long-term, and what will be withheld? If you live abroad, apply for a lower deduction certificate before you sign.
  4. What does your agreement say about transfer? Consent, conditions and fee, in writing, before you agree a price.
  5. Can your lender close cleanly? Ask for the payoff figure and when the original agreement comes back.
  6. Can you carry the flat to the filed possession date, and past it? Remaining instalments, then a full EMI, against the rent you expect.

If holding is the answer, the risk you keep is the date. ReraGenie's free project page shows a project's first promised possession date beside the current one and every extension with the promoter's stated reason, and a Rs 299 project watch emails you when that project's filing changes.

What Rohit decided

He declined. The offer would have left him about Rs 1.4 lakh short with Rs 8.8 lakh withheld until his return was processed, and a sale would have needed a new power of attorney, since the one drafted for his letting plan covers only the letting, and one signed abroad must be notarised, apostilled or attested, and stamped in Maharashtra within three months of arriving (the NRI buyer's playbook). Holding has its arithmetic too: about Rs 60 lakh of loan once fully disbursed, an EMI of about Rs 50,200 at an illustrative 8 percent over 20 years, twice the Rs 25,000 rent he expects. He told the broker any later offer must count the stamp duty credit and the GST its buyer would not pay again, put his agreement's third anniversary in his calendar beside the project's filed completion date, not yet extended, and kept paying.

What the buyer report shows for this decision

For a covered Maharashtra project, the Rs 499 ReraGenie buyer report sets out:

  • The possession story: the first promised completion date against the current one, which a holder bets on and a buyer of the booking prices.
  • Construction pace against the district: whether the progress filed so far makes the current date plausible.
  • Sanctions, units and sales building by building, where the filing carries unit counts: how much of your building the builder still has to sell, your buyer's alternative.

It includes the project's filed documents as a ZIP and a free 90-day project watch.

Methodology and sources

  • Market: ANAROCK, top seven cities, July to September 2026, reported by Business Today on 29 September 2026.
  • Stamp duty: Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958, Schedule I, Article 5(g-a)(ii), three-year window from 1 May 2022.
  • Tax: CBDT Circular 471 of 15 October 1986; tribunal rulings on the allotment letter; Income-tax Act, 2025, sections 197 and 393(2).
  • Arithmetic: ReraGenie, on the story's illustrative figures.

This article is educational and not tax advice. Confirm the figures for your own case with a chartered accountant.

Evaluating a project right now?

The ReraGenie buyer report reads every filing for one project and sets out the red flags, the checks that came back clear and what to verify before you book, each fact with its filing date. Rs 499, one time.

See the buyer report